How To Comment Blogs

by Jefferson Reid · View Comments

This is a guest post written by Jefferson Reid [follow him @jeffersonreid on Twitter.]

Commenting a blog is simple. Yet doing it properly seems a challenge that’s so beyond most people, I feel a remedial session is in order. Allow me to lend a hand, or maybe just a finger. Here goes:

FLIPoff .
.
.
.
.
.
.1.) First, read the blog, or at least skim it.
For Generation PlayStation people, simply look at the pictures.
.
.
Jesus
.
2.) After that tiresome interlude, it’s time to comment. The initial part of your comment should refer to the blog in some glancing way. It wouldn’t hurt to insert a faux civility here, something bland like: “nice blog,” or “good read,” or “pithy and trenchant.” Whew! That was exhausting. If you have anything left in the tank at this point, mention something specific from the blog that you pretended to enjoy, or really did like.
.
FIST
.
3.) Now, feel free to go Proustian on that mofo and totally rewrite their blog in your own words. Better yet, veer off on another topic, thereby showing the writer what their post really should have been about. I’m sure they’ll thank you for it later.
.
.
.
.
MotherWaggingFinger4.) Of course, when a blog is truly a reeking pile of excrement, especially one with a video, please follow your mom’s advice: If you can’t say something nice, don’t say anything at all. Clam up. Then again, mom was never on YouTube being force-fed “spoofs” of Star Wars movies done in Lego animation rife with fart jokes and kick-in-the-nads footage. While admiring the technical chops required to make a light saber cut through a video fart-cloud made of Legos, I’m sure your mom would tell you that this is unnecessary and really “not very nice.”
.
FingerINhole
5.) If you’re forced to watch one of these turds, however, feel free to summon all the vitriol you can muster and unload bigtime. But please do us all a favor and avoid the stale complaint that goes something like this: “Thanks. I’ll never get that 2:37 back again.”
I always want to ask these timeless commenters: What more-productive activity were your planning to do with that time on YouTube?
.
.
PeaceSign.
6.) Also, as a commenter, if some blogger has the audacity to be smarter or funnier or better looking than you, it is your right, nay, your duty, to slag him or her anonymously. But since not every site allows anonymous posts, you’ll often have to troll-up and create a fake name like, Anne Nonimus, Ima Spectre or N. Scrutable.
.
.
.
.
Do it, because spreading the hate in the comments section is not only a civic duty, it makes for compelling drama and drives traffic to the blog you’re excoriating. Who doesn’t love drama? The ancient Greeks had Sophocles, Aristophanes, Euripides and Evenmoreofthese, but we’ve got blog-comment flame wars. Best of all, you don’t need to get dressed up (or even dressed) to be a part of this theater of the unheard.

Are there more commenting commandments that I’ve overlooked? Let me know.
No need for stone tablets, just tell everyone all about them in the comments section below.
.
————————
[Subscribe to ctkingston.com by email subscription or RSS feed -> AND the new BuzzVoice audio feed is available LISTEN To Ct Kingston posts. Subscribe!]

  • Share/Bookmark

Previous post:

Next post:

  • Jefferson Reid, you rocked this! Postwise and Comment replywise. You're the bomb-diggty. Thanks for guesting:)
  • This is a great tutorial and I have learned much after 1) skimming it, especially point (2) in which you said, and I quote "The initial part of your comment should refer to the blog in some glancing way." That being said and out of the way, I have to say I find the topic of pingbacks a fascinating topic and I'm wondering why this was not mentioned in this post about comments? Despite the picture of Jesus which I thought, naturally, would be a lead in to the topic of pingbacks and linkbacks. Or at least mentioned.
    Pingbacks and linkbacks are great, and offer a valuable service to the blogging community, but what troubles me is that whenever one receives a pingback, wordpress sends a notification and asks the pingback to be approved or denied. I always deny them. (This is strictly a matter of principal.) But the articles refering back to my article remain intact, even days after I have denied it.
    Also, you did not give any advice about how to get your comments approved when they are written in Russian. I have written dozens of comments in Russian, with links to various websites offering free software downloads and discounted pharmaceuticals as a valuable service to your readers, but they have never been approved.
    In any event, I thank you for this article on comments. As a reward, I sent you two oversized rubber boots through "Sheepville" on your facebook and twitter accounts. You should send me a gift back too!!
    Kind Regards,
    Дэвид
  • jeffersonreid
    David,
    Your Dilations On the Pingback should be required reading for all Blogistas, it is a marvelous manifesto of sorts, or out of sorts, as the case my be. I'm sure that your vaporization technique for articles linking to yours may yet succeed. Keep pressing that button. Sorry about the Russian Warez correspondence oversight. What I probably should have said was:
    Вставай, проклятьем заклеймённый,
    Весь мир голодных и рабов!
    Кипит наш разум возмущённый
    И в смертный бой вести готов.
    Весь мир насилья мы разрушим
    До основанья, а затем
    Мы наш, мы новый мир построим, —
    Кто был ничем, тот станет всем.

    Припев:

    |: Это есть наш последний
    И решительный бой.
    С Интернационалом
    Воспрянет род людской!

    Dosvidanya!
  • This is the hardest I have laughed at a blog post for weeks. Hilarious explanation of MY inbox full of you tube videos.
  • jeffersonreid
    Thanks. Glad you got my videos. Make sure you watch them all the way til the end, even the bloopers.
  • Now that this has become more of a serious and open discussion, I would like to put my best foot forward. http://www.twitpic.com/fqo3l
  • jeffersonreid
    You are definitely kicking it large-style with this vast assortment of kicks. Your footwear options are formidable, and clearly adequate to the task of blog-posting in a manner appropriate to today's teens, young adults and the various vintage types who traverse the myriad pathways of the social media nexus of marginal employment/excess free time. If you haven't directly asserted a new path toward blog commenting, you've certainly posited a foot-oriented framework for said ramblings. Bravo!
  • jeannevb
    my son has something to say http://www.twitpic.com/yfvhv
  • jeannevb
    I'd suggest this as an effective way to comment on blogs http://www.twitpic.com/q8k22
  • That comment's the sh!t right there.
  • jeffersonreid
    That comment's the sh!t right there.
  • jeannevb
    umm... that's very interesting... but let's talk about my kitchen http://www.twitpic.com/hj1ay
  • jeffersonreid
    That is some of the hottest kitchen-remodeling p0rn I've ever seem. It's like an open-concept, open-marriage embrace-the-lifestyle granite countertops and stainless steel appliances orgy of convenience. Sizzling!
  • landice
    I laughed a lot at this. It seems to be the code for commenters sometimes, I agree. Damn no-mannered people.
  • Hehehe.. Good read. Learned a lot. Interesting that why you picked finger arts as graphics go along with the writing.. Don't give me wrong.. Funny, not complaining at all. Good choice for a guest post, Tina!! :-)
  • LOVE IT!! LOL
    That's great! Now what I would have said...

    Andrew Rodgers
  • Andrew, thanks for the qood word. LOL-ing right back atcha!
  • laineyd7
    Hilarious post, Jefferson, and all of the comments a cloud of delightfully (yet useless) Lego farts!
  • Your comment was also a gas, gas, gas--though thankfully not of that odious species, Legolatious Flatulatus.
  • Batman
    Sites like YouTube and Flickr have a character limit for your comment, therefore, I believe that you should use them all. I would rewrite your blog entry above, but since it's a guest post....
  • jeffersonreid
    Holy taking it to the limit, Batman! The power of infinity actually drives shorter comments then. How paradoxical!
  • Would it hve killed you to include the fart Lego video? Sheesh! Also if you're commenting you should take the time to read all the other comments to make sure you're not repeating someone else's comment. Hopefully no one else has put this up, because I don't have time to read all the other comments. I have to take a nap now. (Funny blog, Jefferson!)
  • Marty, thanks for the good word. Very funny comment, or so my assistant tells me. I haven't had time to read it yet myself, but I have it penciled in for later this week. %^)
  • Did you know that the average crustacean has a lifespan of 23 years? Who wants a goldfish that's 23 years old? Dogs don't give you that much responsibility.

    WaReZ RuLeZ
  • Something fishy with this whole analysis if you ask me. Since a goldfish only has a 23 second memory loop to work from, that makes for a lot of repetition in a year though blessedly mitigated by instant amnesia. It reminds me of a math problem involving dogs on social networking sites. If a labradoodle boards a train going 3/4 the speed of light passes another train heading in the opposite direction that only makes local stops, how many cases of shingles will it take to roof the barn.
  • @McFearless1
    You so RAWK miss! Thanks for bollging as hott as you look miss!
  • ninibaseema
    Im just giggling my ass off here. This is hilarious.
    Sir Jeffers what do you think? Would this young lad "pass" the test. I shall say, probably NO ;-)

    Dont worry Eddie, we still love you anyways ;*
  • :-) Thanks hon! But this is a 'guest post' written by @JeffersonReid ...I love taking the credit for it though! Weeee! Thanks for stopping by! Make it a ritual!
  • You forgot:
    7) Thinly veil a shameless plug for your own site with a condescending reference to how to the post relates to your own (obviously better) blog. Hotlinked phrases like "in a similar article" and "reminds me of...","i recently discussed this topic..." help readers to make the transition to your site with minimal effort.

    [ss]
  • Sherwin. You have hit the nail on the head. That is something I should have included, the narcissistically driven redirecters. Those folks only ever write about a meme because they think it is saying, "Me me"!
  • Hilarious!
  • jonikennedy
    Nice pictures, Jefferson!I think I would have put them in a different order though. Thanks ,I'll never get this 50 seconds back again. Now excuse me I've got a game of Guitar Hero waiting for me. Great post!!! You made me laugh!! p.s. can you post the link to the Lego animation with fart jokes?
  • Sorry about your 50 seconds and good luck with that Guitar Hero. I think you should use that gamey axe to compose the ultimate ode to flatulent Legos with a Star Wars twist. I'd love to hear that hit single!
  • Qudsia Sadiq
    Kudcia here again... jeffersonreid This was truly an amazing post! kudos to you!
  • Quidsia, You are so right about those veering-with-the-steering types who want to redirect the convo to Planet Them. Big ups on the good word right back atcha!
  • Qudsia Sadiq
    Kudcia here. You crack me up but you're so right! :)

    One thing I can't stand about individuals who comment is when they take your post into a completely separate direction and make you feel like a complete fool. Woo them!

    It does create drama, hype and all that jazz but then again (to all you smart-asses out there who see good in nothing) it also makes me use that part of my brain which I want to rest for that moment. So all in all don't piss me off when you don't know what I'm on about. If you have an opinion make it sound like one and stop behaving like a mother I never wanted to have! :)

    Rest, Tina pretty much took care of everything else any writer or I would want to say. And mind you ( not you Tina) this has nothing to do with not being able to take criticism or opinions and all that crap you think I 'might' be on about. It's purely directed towards those people who love commenting mindlessly.

    Excellent post and a much needed one. Not many talk about it. Different and very entertaining.
  • ninibaseema
    Ahh Sir Jeffers, thanks for your elaborate instructions. You showed it to us all once more:
    Blog commenting IS an art itself!

    Did take severe notes in order to be able to provide sufficient blog answering quality in the future.

    Kind regards
    NINI

    PS "If you can’t say something nice, don’t say anything at all" Need to remember that - definitely and desperately!
  • jeffersonreid
    You have clearly mastered the art, though I'm not sure if any of us can live up to the dictum: "If you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all"...though of course the Cosmic Mom in all of us wants us to try.
  • This is absolute shit. Who adds a post like the one above to the fine comment I'd written below? Geez...

    "Thanks for your kind advice. I was searching internet for just this type thing! I find this to be very information. Now come to my nice store and buy your drugs online!"

    My comment was sitting there in cyberspace enjoying itself and then suddenly it finds a post attached to it, explaining how to make comments, when clearly... I already know how to make comments!

    EVERYONE knows that the purpose of comments is to make a thinly veiled attempt at luring people to your online drugs store in broken [insert language of blog here]. Right?
  • Jefferson Reid
    Pure genius of cosmic proportions. If my blog post had not existed, it would be necessary to create it in order to house your comment. Everyone make sure to buy Mookie's online drugs. I understand that they are spun from the finest Persian Placebos.
  • nsedef
    very funny and entertaining, Jefferson. You did the @CTK1 blog proud.
  • That sincerity bomb just detonated while I was reading it. Thanks!
  • Good read!

    I liked the part where it said how to comment blogs!
  • Agreed. That part about how to comment blogs was sweet! Validation accepted.
  • Isn't that Josh a cutie? heh
  • You're really letting your blog go, CT, by letting guest bloggers post such pithy trash as this. I'll never get that four minutes and 34 seconds back that it took me to skim this.

    Just Kidding!

    I totally got a laugh out of this. Good job.
  • I wear your mark of Pithy Trash as a badge of honor. Sorry about your 4:34, but if it makes you feel any better, I've given you at least that much back on this tiny response. Cheers!
  • Blogs suck. I only comment on magazines, which have the phone numbers of extremely unimportant people who didn't have anything to do with the actual production of the work that I can call up and scream my vengeance at.
  • Excellent option for dialing drunk, G. It allows you to act your rage with no repercussions. Hopefully, @ctk1 will be able to implement some such call-in feature for future posts.
  • James Bond
    Nice writing. I especially appreciated the use of adjectives and YouTube references. I will post a link from my site to here so that I can get some more...err....feedback....

    You did forget to mention that the commenter should always ask if the post was written about them... as in..."Was I the lady you mentioned when you wrote about picking the lint off of someone's caboose?"

    Thank you so much for amusing me!
  • Jefferson Reid
    Excellent point, Bondi. And smoove moove remaining anonymous. It's what a double-naught spy ought to do.
  • I don't think I've ever seen a bigger pile of steaming feces than this guest post. I mean seriously, my dog writes better than this. And he eats his own vomit.

    Sincerely,

    Anne Nonimus
  • I do believe that Anne Nonimus would have worked better had you not signed in with your Disqus account. Jus' sayin'... ;-)
  • Ah, but then it wouldn't be clearly tongue-in-cheek, would it? ;)
  • Jefferson Reid
    Yes, I know. This blog post IS the sh!t. Best to your dog and his b!tch (I think her name is Nate)
  • Well played, sir. Well played.
  • Och aye th' noo but this is a grand post, is it no'? But wha' telt ye that ye hud tae be aw clever and recite the post back? It's no' as if ah didnae huv enuff recital shenanigans tae learn frae that eejit Rabbie Burns - dinnae tell me ah huv tae learn a blog poast an' aw?

    Jings, crivvens and help ma' boab!
  • Jefferson Reid
    Cam ye o' fra France, cam ye doon by Loonun? Saw ye Jordie Whelps, and his bonnie woman? Just sayin'...
  • jeannevb
    I normally have no problem commenting, but now that I've had a lesson, I feel frigid. See, I already got it wrong... let me start again...

    Nice blog, Jefferson! WOOHOO! I learned a lot. Everyone should read this before they read my blog. They'll leave better comments.

    The pictures were pretty. But why are there so many fingers? Why aren't any of these fingers wearing rings? I like rings. Tina picks out great rings. You should have used her fingers.

    Anonymous
  • Jefferson Reid
    Jeanne, sorry to give you Comment Stage Fright, but you seem to have recovered nicely! I was suffering the same fate trying to respond to your appreciative comment, so I used your technique of thinking about baubles to help me through this troubled moment. And it worked! You should write about this on your blog. I'd be happy to coach you through it. %^)
  • Nice blog, good read, pithy and trenchant. Seriously, hilarious! I do think you were a little tough on the Lego YouTube animations, they are almost as creative and useless as those giant domino creations.
  • jeffersonreid
    Thanks Roger. I'm appointing you President of Pith. Unfortunately, this is an honorary position sans honorarium. That's life, or blogging anyway. :) You're right about those dominoes and their creative uselessness, which is one fun way to live life. Also, def trumps Lego fart clouds.
blog comments powered by Disqus